So is the B.C. economy driven by the natural resource sector or not? You'll be hearing conflicting answers to that question in the months and years ahead as debate swirls on whether to build various mega-projects, but the issue goes to the heart of where B.C.'s economy is headed.
Last week, two groups released what appeared to be contradictory reports on the importance of the energy industry to B.C.'s overall economic health. A closer look, however, shows there may be more common ground between the two views than first thought.
One group, called the Conversations for Responsible Economic Development (CRED), published a study that questions the premise that B.C. is a resource-based province. Using a variety of government statistics, it makes the case that three quarters of our economic activity is, in fact, derived from the service industry.
On the other hand, CRED argues just 11 per cent of the province's gross domestic product comes from the energy sector. The organization, whose philosophy seems to tilt toward greenish, small business-oriented values, is trying to make the point that industries like mining, forestry and energy are dwarfed by real estate, retail and various service industries when it comes to having an impact on the economy.
Another organization, calling itself "British Columbians for Prosperity" put out its own report that claims building those two pipelines from Alberta's oil sands - the Northern Gateway and Kinder Morgan pipelines - would create almost 10,000 jobs and generate more than $11 billion in economic activity.
Two reports, two completely different takes on a key part of our economy. So who's correct? Well, both perhaps.
The common link here is the construction industry.
Both CRED and the Prosperity group agree the construction industry plays a vital role in building B.C.'s economy. What the CRED report does not do is link construction jobs to the huge economic spinoffs associated with various energy projects on the drawing board.
For example, BC Hydro estimates a staggering 33,000 jobs would be created in the construction and development phase of the Site C dam project, as it makes its case for the megaproject to go ahead.
The B.C. government estimates that if five liquified natural gas plants are built in the northwest (an admittedly ambitious and perhaps unrealistic plan) that 39,000 construction jobs would be created. Throw in those pipeline job estimates, and we could be looking at a whopping 80,000 new construction jobs being created over the next decade.
Those estimates could be much too high. But even if half those jobs come to fruition, they will have a substantial impact on B.C.'s economy, not least because they will all be well-paying jobs that create a lot of economic activity.
And we should hope at least some of those jobs do indeed materialize. If they don't, a lot of young people are going to find themselves stuck in dead-end jobs (like many in the service sector) that don't pay much and make living in an expensive area like Metro Vancouver almost impossible.
British Columbia appears headed to a crossroads. Job creation has been stagnant in this province for several years now, despite the B.C. Liberal government's lofty B.C. Jobs Plan. While we may not presently be as reliant on the natural resource sector as is commonly perceived, it may be in our economic self- interest to ensure we are in the future.
NDP MLA Jenny Kwan is on an unpaid leave of absence as she tries to come to grips with a spending scandal that has wounded her credibility, and I suspect there are a few New Democrats who are secretly smiling about this.
Kwan, you'll recall, was a prime instigator of the coup that forced Carole James out as the NDP leader, and a number of party folks have never forgiven her for that. Now the MLA - known for castigating the government for not doing enough to combat poverty - has had to dip into her own pocket and pay back almost $35,000 to the Portland Hotel Society for spending incurred by her estranged husband and herself on several trips. It will be interesting to see how Kwan fares in the legislature when she returns from her leave.
